ACLU: How “Stay-or-Pay” Contracts Are Used to Abuse Immigrant Workers https://ift.tt/stKTLD3
Shiny Lal is a nurse who came to the U.S. from India at the peak of the COVID-19 epidemic. In a new country facing an unprecedented virus, she dedicated herself to the difficult, dangerous work of front-line caregiving to create a better life for her family. But it wasn’t long before her American dream turned into a nightmare. Her employer, MedPro Healthcare Staffing, is among the growing number of companies that force employees to sign “stay-or-pay” contracts. These agreements impose exorbitant fees – routinely in the tens of thousands of dollars – under the guise of recouping training and relocation expenses if a worker leaves their job too soon. In Shiny’s case, the penalty – up to $40,000 plus MedPro’s enforcement costs – was triggered if she spent fewer than three years working for the company.
MedPro placed Shiny in a small-town hospital in Kentucky where she was underpaid and struggled with an abusive supervisor. Shiny begged MedPro for a reassignment, but nothing changed. After enduring months of unbearable working conditions, Shiny resigned, hoping for a fresh start. But MedPro came after her, as it has pursued other former employees. MedPro filed a complaint against Shiny with the American Arbitration Association (AAA), the world’s largest private dispute resolution company. Without hearing Shiny’s side of the story, the AAA arbitrator rubber-stamped MedPro’s request for almost $36,000 in damages and penalties. Shiny only learned about the ruling many months later when MedPro sued to collect the judgment.
A photo of Shiny Lal.
Shiny is far from the only one who has faced the devastating impact of stay-or-pay contracts. According to one estimate, employers use these contracts in an array of fields, including health care, trucking, education, and aviation. Combined, these industries employ 52 million people, or one-third of all U.S. workers. Employers typically use arbitration, a dispute resolution process where a private third party makes a binding decision on a dispute between two parties, to enforce these agreements, which the U.S. Department of Labor, the National Labor Relations Board, and several courts have been found to violate federal and state labor statutes and human trafficking laws.
Women – particularly immigrant women – and workers of color disproportionately hold the low-wage jobs where stay-or-pay contracts are most common, and disproportionately suffer the consequences of what is both a workers’ rights issue and a civil rights issue. Indeed, it isn’t an overstatement to call stay-or-pay contracts a form of indentured servitude where workers are forced to remain in substandard working conditions unless they are willing to risk financial ruin.
Today, the ACLU Women’s Rights Project and Towards Justice, along with 12 organizations called on the AAA to stop helping abusive employers enforce stay-or-pay contracts against their workers by refusing to accept such cases.
To understand just how harmful these contracts can be, the ACLU recently spoke with Shiny about her experience fighting the AAA ruling to free herself from this abusive contract and so she can return to the care-work that brought her to the states. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
ACLU: What inspired you to pursue a nursing career in the U.S.? What was your experience like moving and adapting to life here?
SHINY: I first filed to come to the U.S. in 2007 and had to wait 14 years for my application to be approved. It was a long-term dream of mine to be a nurse in a foreign country that had more modern equipment and better facilities. When I did calculations to convert my salary in dollars to rupees, it looked like I would be making good money. My husband, my children and I left everything we had in India to chase the American dream.
MedPro placed me at a hospital that was very remote and had no public transportation. I didn’t have a car or a driver’s license and I had to walk two miles in either direction to work and depend on neighbors to bring us groceries. Eventually I found a better apartment and purchased a second-hand car, but those expenses took up a lot of my salary. My husband couldn’t find a job, and my daughter couldn’t attend college because no one could travel anywhere. It was isolating and scary.
I asked for a different placement where I could have more resources and community, but MedPro knew they didn’t have to accommodate me because leaving the job could ruin me.
ACLU: Before signing, what was your understanding of the “stay or pay” contracts?
SHINY: I knew there would be a penalty for leaving my MedPro job before I’d worked there for three years, but I never imagined I would leave. I thought those three years would go by fast, and that life in the U.S. would be much better than it had been in India. It was only once it was too late that I understood how the contract opened me up to being mistreated by my employer and kept me stuck in a situation that I didn’t feel like I could get out of.
"It was only once it was too late that I understood how the contract opened me up to being mistreated by my employer and kept me stuck in a situation that I didn’t feel like I could get out of."
ACLU: How was your job with MedPro different from your expectations?
SHINY: MedPro contracted me to the hospital as a travel nurse, who often gets the hardest assignments in exchange for higher pay, so I was expected to deal with the most difficult patients. But I was earning less than the other staff nurses, not more, and had a hard time adjusting to a new medical system without any sort of guidance.
Soon after I started working, my supervisor began to treat me worse than other nurses, refusing to train me and blaming me for mistakes I hadn’t made. MedPro kept promising that I could switch supervisors, but nothing changed.
ACLU: What ultimately led you to resign your position with MedPro?
SHINY: After several weeks of repeated complaints, I was just told to quit. For a few months, I was forced to survive on a stipend of $350 per week while I waited for another placement, which was so low that I had to start borrowing money from friends to meet my family’s most basic needs. My husband ended up getting ill and had to return to India to receive care, leaving me alone with our two children. Looking back, I can’t imagine how I got through that time. I didn’t know what to do and nobody was there to help me.
After a few months, MedPro placed me at another job, but my debts were piling up. I would be in debt whether I stayed or quit, but if I found a new job with better pay, at least I could start to work my way out of it. So I gave notice to MedPro that I was resigning.
ACLU: How did you feel when you first found out about the AAA arbitration proceedings and the amount you were being asked to pay?
SHINY: After I gave notice, MedPro demanded that I pay them $26,666.68. I was shocked by how high that amount was, especially knowing how much money they had already made off my work. They were charging the hospital $150 an hour, and I was only earning $27 of that. I tried to negotiate, offering to pay $10,000, but they refused anything less than the full amount.
After I realized that I wasn’t getting anywhere, I stopped responding to their emails. I didn’t have the money to pay them and I didn’t have the money to pay a lawyer to represent me against them, so it felt like there was nothing I could do.
ACLU: What happens next with your case?
SHINY: Although I wasn’t aware that the arbitration was happening, the arbitrator entered an award against me for $36,592.87. This amount included $12,000 in damages paid to MedPro for the recruiter who I worked with in India, more than $20,000 for my orientation, and around $6,500 for something called “cost of capital,” prorated based on how much time I worked. It also included around $6,500 in interest and $3,500 to cover MedPro’s attorney fees. .
For a year after the award, I didn’t hear anything from MedPro, but in October 2024 I was served with a lawsuit they filed to get a court to confirm the arbitration award. The nonprofit Towards Justice had helped me file a charge with the National Labor Relations Board, but I’m still waiting for a resolution, and I can’t afford a lawyer to defend me against MedPro’s case in court. I am scared that MedPro will get a judgment against me, and I feel hopeless about defending myself.
ACLU: How has this contract and lawsuit impacted your life?
SHINY: I’ve found a new job in a totally different environment that’s much more relaxed and supportive, and I’m finally able to live the life I came here for. My husband’s health improved and he was able to move back to the United States, so my family has been reunited. But I still have the lawsuit hanging over my head, and paying the debt is still impossible. I don’t want all of the work I’ve done towards the American Dream to fall apart. I didn’t understand how easy it was to take away my rights, and how powerless I would be to provide for my family.
I am not to fundamentalist about life, like if it happens I as a human being have little control over it
on some levels my life would improve as a newly minted United States citizen it would be super strange cause we have a unique identity here
but being able to carry a gun -tazer or whatever legally would be pretty cool
actually having acceptable health care would be pretty cool even though you have to pay for it
it would shower canadians with untold riches and rights beyond our wildest imaginations
I think it would be so cool to play powerball and megamillions lottery for $1B a shot since our highest lottery here is $80M
my mother church ULC is a modesto based church been around forever they basically give me the legal right to use Rev Dr before my name, like I could officially start my own ministry legally within canada as a united states mother church and make a living possibly doing reverend shit like weddings not that I would want 2
I would not put it past Queen Charles to sell us all honestly
its like why kill yourself over something that could actually be quite good?
it would be a logistical mess like identification wise
jobs investments it would be totally insane but that makes me think that it may never be done it would be too incredibly complex like with everyones mortgages and money etc it would cause a lot of chaos like switching our banknotes
but this acquisition of Canada Greenland and panama would pretty much wipe out the United states national debt
as you can tell I switch allegiances pretty quick
still gonna hold people accountable for spiritual incursions its my job as an interfaith and multifaith minister
but honestly like anybody I admire you have to show yourself making solid decisions with your power for the guru to respect you - lock everyone away in camps and take off their skin would not be a very nice action when you said there would be a united states golden age a time of awakening and enlightenment lol
its like Girl we have no choice in most of what we do...maybe 3-5% but no more like duh? freemasons maybe 15-20% but so much is Way beyond our control like control and power wise :P
.jpg)
